MAGIC

  1. I should try to define “magic”


  2. According to Google,
    1. “Magic” is the power of apparently influencing the course of events by using mysterious or supernatural forces
    1. The supernatural refers to events, forces, or entities that exist outside of the natural world and cannot be explained by known scientific laws or empirical observation. This concept encompasses phenomena that transcend ordinary human experience.

Magic: three possible kinds

  • Three kinds of POSSIBLE things or events that we call “magic” or  “magical”
    • Fake (the magic of Magicians)
    • Things, or events that are CURRENTLY unexplainable
    • Things, or events that really ARE in fact, somehow, “above” cause and effect – actually are unexplainable
  • That probably doesn’t help a whole lot — maybe EXAMPLES will do better
    • The Creator
    • Souls
    • Free will
  • Unfortunately, there are, other, examples of magic, that most of us humans just take for granted — as NOT being magical…
    • EXISTENCE in general
    • AWARENESS in general
    • MY EXISTENCE/AWARENESS in particular
    • If anyone else is reading this, YOUR EXISTENCE/AWARENESS in particular


  • But first, why would FREE WILL be magical?
    • Most of us humans figure that we do have free will, in that our behavior is the result of external realities (biology and experience) but also of OUR OWN TRAITS AND VALUES
    • The problem, however, is that our own ORIGINAL traits and values MUST HAVE BEEN DETERMINED BY EXTERNAL REALITIES also — we could hardly be responsible for our own traits and values BEFORE we existed
    • Taking that into account, cause and effect SHOULD rule
    • In other words, our behavior would seem to be COMPLETELY determined by external realities — and if so, free will is simply impossible
    • In more other words — I can “PROVE” that there is no such thing as free will and that NO ONE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ANYTHING!!!
    • However, I TEND TO BELIEVE IN FREE WILL ANYWAY!
    • Most likely, you do also
    • Either I — and probably you — are wrong, or the experts are missing something crucial…
    • (I do have possible explanations as to WHAT the experts are missing, and WHY they have missed it)
    • If free will is real, you and I ARE simply “magical” — WE ARE SOMEHOW ABOVE THE LAWS OF CAUSE AND EFFECT
    • If so, we are little Gods — perhaps, we are parts of God
    • Perhaps, we are parts of a “universal consciousness” (Quantum Mechanics is promoting such a concept)
    • If we have free will, we are at least, LIKE little Gods — and, cause and effect DOES NOT rule!
    • And reality must at least INCLUDE some “magic”
  • EXISTENCE
    • I’m claiming that EXISTENCE ITSELF is magical
    • NOTHING existing would make PERFECT sense
    • Obviously, NOTHING existing would require absolutely NO explanation…
    • Whereas, SOMETHING existing would require AN INFINITY OF EXPLANATIONS — if cause and effect rules (if cause and effect rules, how could there be a cause that was not itself caused?)
    • But then, how could there be an infinity of causes either?
    • Again, I’m suggesting that, somehow, cause and effect DOES NOT RULE…
    • And, existence IN GENERAL is, itself, magical
    • We have a LONG way to go to understand existence – if, that is even possible
    • Remember – the UNIVERSE (reality) somehow BEGAN…!
  • CONSCIOUSNESS in general…
  • MY OWN PERSONAL CONSCIOUSNESS in particular
  • And, if anyone else is reading this, YOUR OWN PERSONAL CONSCIOUSNESS in particular, as well


  • Note that, the “lower” animals seem to “TAKE MOST EVERYTHING FOR GRANTED” – i.e., we humans assume that the lower animals never (or, hardly ever) wonder about “how” or “why” things, or events, exist or happen
  • The lower animals appear to just REACT in whatever ways that they perceive to be in their own (or a loved one’s) best interest
  • Whereas, we humans DO wonder how and why about most everything
  • However, there does seem to be something UTTERLY AMAZING about existence that almost all of us humans do, in fact, just take for granted (as if, for some reason, it doesn’t require an explanation)
  • We don’t tend to notice that we’re doing this


  • Again, I’ll try to explain…
  • Apparently, homo-sapiens have existed for 200,000 years and have produced about 100,000,000,000 (ONE-HUNDRED BILLION) examples (“selves”)
  • If each of us selves can exist for only one finite time at most, there must be an INFINITY of POTENTIAL selves!!!
  • But only about 8 billion  of us CURRENTLY exist
  • If so, the PROBABILITY of me CURRENTLY existing (as a human being) must be about 8 billion over infinity — i.e. virtually zero!!!
  • If anyone else is reading this, the same goes for you
  • In other words, it must be that you and I exist MANY, MANY times — or ALL of time
  • Most likely, you and I are simply BASIC to reality, and if reality always exists, we must also…


  • Did something exist before reality?
  • Is there a different kind of existence?
  • Hitching a ride on Quantum Mechanics, you and I must be specific divisions of an infinitely divisible UNIVERSAL CONSCIOUSNESS (please look that one up!)
  • And, at the “BEGINNING OF TIME,” (if there WAS such a thing) we must ALL have been ONE
  • I suggest that ALMOST NO ONE recognizes this amazing aspect of his/her own existence because it is so difficult to describe — consequently, so far, each of us needs to recognize this for him/her self

  • Though, I’ll keep trying to help…
  • In other words…
  • WHERE (IN THE HELL!) DID I COME FROM?!!!
  • Did I exist in some other form before I was conceived?
  • Or, was I brand new?
  • So far, that might be the best I can do towards describing what is so amazing about my own existence…
  • And, please keep in mind my suggestion that we homo-sapiens. are only in our evolutionary “childhood,” not nearly as smart as we think we are — and consequently, fail to notice/realize SOMETHING crucial about reality
  • I’m claiming that there is something amazing/magical about our own existences THAT ALMOST NO ONE NOTICES…
  • And, those who notice, don’t know how to describe it
  • Abraham Joshua Heschel (a preeminent Jewish theologian) apparently DID notice, and called it “RADICAL AMAZEMENT”
  • But even Heschel couldn’t describe it well enough for me to be sure that he and I were perceiving the same thing
  • These apparent MAGICAL facts must be largely RESPONSIBLE for our religions – for our tendency towards BELIEVING in magic and ultimate meaning, even though we can’t explain why
  • So, one of those FACTS that we should probably NOT take for granted, but do, is our own SELVES
  • When carefully analyzed, our own selves just don’t fit what we think we know about reality…
  • And again, such facts end up supporting/suggesting, Religion…
  • We take our selves for granted — when our selves are the very last “things” that we SHOULD take for granted
  • Am I just one of the infinity of potential selves?
  • NOTHING existing would make perfect sense, whereas MY PARTICULAR EXISTENCE makes absolutely NO sense — especially RIGHT NOW
  • Again, WHERE IN THE HELL DID I COME FROM, anyway?!
  • We’ve just taken our personal existences and awarenesses for granted — but they are nowhere near DESERVING of such…


  • So, most of our public schools and universities in the West have been essentially DISCOUNTING religion — and in general, the more education we receive in the West, the LESS religious we become
  • I suggest that the reason this negation persists is that the serious evidence AGAINST belief is just much more OBVIOUS than is the serious evidence FOR belief   (And once again, intellectually speaking, we humans are probably in our evolutionary childhood)
  • And then, the evidence FOR belief – once recognized – is almost impossible to discount…

MAGIC

  1. I should try to define “magic”


  2. According to Google,
    1. “Magic” is the power of apparently influencing the course of events by using mysterious or supernatural forces
    1. The supernatural refers to events, forces, or entities that exist outside of the natural world and cannot be explained by known scientific laws or empirical observation. This concept encompasses phenomena that transcend ordinary human experience.

Magic: three possible kinds

  • Three kinds of POSSIBLE things or events that we call “magic” or  “magical”
    • Fake (the magic of Magicians)
    • Things, or events that are CURRENTLY unexplainable
    • Things, or events that really ARE in fact, somehow, “above” cause and effect – actually are unexplainable
  • That probably doesn’t help a whole lot — maybe EXAMPLES will do better
    • The Creator
    • Souls
    • Free will
  • Unfortunately, there are, other, examples of magic, that most of us humans just take for granted — as NOT being magical…
    • EXISTENCE in general
    • AWARENESS in general
    • MY EXISTENCE/AWARENESS in particular
    • If anyone else is reading this, YOUR EXISTENCE/AWARENESS in particular


  • But first, why would FREE WILL be magical?
    • Most of us humans figure that we do have free will, in that our behavior is the result of external realities (biology and experience) but also of OUR OWN TRAITS AND VALUES
    • The problem, however, is that our own ORIGINAL traits and values MUST HAVE BEEN DETERMINED BY EXTERNAL REALITIES also — we could hardly be responsible for our own traits and values BEFORE we existed
    • Taking that into account, cause and effect SHOULD rule
    • In other words, our behavior would seem to be COMPLETELY determined by external realities — and if so, free will is simply impossible
    • In more other words — I can “PROVE” that there is no such thing as free will and that NO ONE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ANYTHING!!!
    • However, I TEND TO BELIEVE IN FREE WILL ANYWAY!
    • Most likely, you do also
    • Either I — and probably you — are wrong, or the experts are missing something crucial…
    • (I do have possible explanations as to WHAT the experts are missing, and WHY they have missed it)
    • If free will is real, you and I ARE simply “magical” — WE ARE SOMEHOW ABOVE THE LAWS OF CAUSE AND EFFECT
    • If so, we are little Gods — perhaps, we are parts of God
    • Perhaps, we are parts of a “universal consciousness” (Quantum Mechanics is promoting such a concept)
    • If we have free will, we are at least, LIKE little Gods — and, cause and effect DOES NOT rule!
    • And reality must at least INCLUDE some “magic”
  • EXISTENCE
    • I’m claiming that EXISTENCE ITSELF is magical
    • NOTHING existing would make PERFECT sense
    • Obviously, NOTHING existing would require absolutely NO explanation…
    • Whereas, SOMETHING existing would require AN INFINITY OF EXPLANATIONS — if cause and effect rules (if cause and effect rules, how could there be a cause that was not itself caused?)
    • But then, how could there be an infinity of causes either?
    • Again, I’m suggesting that, somehow, cause and effect DOES NOT RULE…
    • And, existence IN GENERAL is, itself, magical
    • We have a LONG way to go to understand existence – if, that is even possible
    • Remember – the UNIVERSE (reality) somehow BEGAN…!
  • CONSCIOUSNESS in general…
  • MY OWN PERSONAL CONSCIOUSNESS in particular
  • And, if anyone else is reading this, YOUR OWN PERSONAL CONSCIOUSNESS in particular, as well


  • Note that, the “lower” animals seem to “TAKE MOST EVERYTHING FOR GRANTED” – i.e., we humans assume that the lower animals never (or, hardly ever) wonder about “how” or “why” things, or events, exist or happen
  • The lower animals appear to just REACT in whatever ways that they perceive to be in their own (or a loved one’s) best interest
  • Whereas, we humans DO wonder how and why about most everything
  • However, there does seem to be something UTTERLY AMAZING about existence that almost all of us humans do, in fact, just take for granted (as if, for some reason, it doesn’t require an explanation)
  • We don’t tend to notice that we’re doing this


  • Again, I’ll try to explain…
  • Apparently, homo-sapiens have existed for 200,000 years and have produced about 100,000,000,000 (ONE-HUNDRED BILLION) examples (“selves”)
  • If each of us selves can exist for only one finite time at most, there must be an INFINITY of POTENTIAL selves!!!
  • But only about 8 billion  of us CURRENTLY exist
  • If so, the PROBABILITY of me CURRENTLY existing (as a human being) must be about 8 billion over infinity — i.e. virtually zero!!!
  • If anyone else is reading this, the same goes for you
  • In other words, it must be that you and I exist MANY, MANY times — or ALL of time
  • Most likely, you and I are simply BASIC to reality, and if reality always exists, we must also…


  • Did something exist before reality?
  • Is there a different kind of existence?
  • Hitching a ride on Quantum Mechanics, you and I must be specific divisions of an infinitely divisible UNIVERSAL CONSCIOUSNESS (please look that one up!)
  • And, at the “BEGINNING OF TIME,” (if there WAS such a thing) we must ALL have been ONE
  • I suggest that ALMOST NO ONE recognizes this amazing aspect of his/her own existence because it is so difficult to describe — consequently, so far, each of us needs to recognize this for him/her self

  • Though, I’ll keep trying to help…
  • In other words…
  • WHERE (IN THE HELL!) DID I COME FROM?!!!
  • Did I exist in some other form before I was conceived?
  • Or, was I brand new?
  • So far, that might be the best I can do towards describing what is so amazing about my own existence…
  • And, please keep in mind my suggestion that we homo-sapiens. are only in our evolutionary “childhood,” not nearly as smart as we think we are — and consequently, fail to notice/realize SOMETHING crucial about reality
  • I’m claiming that there is something amazing/magical about our own existences THAT ALMOST NO ONE NOTICES…
  • And, those who notice, don’t know how to describe it
  • Abraham Joshua Heschel (a preeminent Jewish theologian) apparently DID notice, and called it “RADICAL AMAZEMENT”
  • But even Heschel couldn’t describe it well enough for me to be sure that he and I were perceiving the same thing
  • These apparent MAGICAL facts must be largely RESPONSIBLE for our religions – for our tendency towards BELIEVING in magic and ultimate meaning, even though we can’t explain why
  • So, one of those FACTS that we should probably NOT take for granted, but do, is our own SELVES
  • When carefully analyzed, our own selves just don’t fit what we think we know about reality…
  • And again, such facts end up supporting/suggesting, Religion…
  • We take our selves for granted — when our selves are the very last “things” that we SHOULD take for granted
  • Am I just one of the infinity of potential selves?
  • NOTHING existing would make perfect sense, whereas MY PARTICULAR EXISTENCE makes absolutely NO sense — especially RIGHT NOW
  • Again, WHERE IN THE HELL DID I COME FROM, anyway?!
  • We’ve just taken our personal existences and awarenesses for granted — but they are nowhere near DESERVING of such…


  • So, most of our public schools and universities in the West have been essentially DISCOUNTING religion — and in general, the more education we receive in the West, the LESS religious we become
  • I suggest that the reason this negation persists is that the serious evidence AGAINST belief is just much more OBVIOUS than is the serious evidence FOR belief   (And once again, intellectually speaking, we humans are probably in our evolutionary childhood)
  • And then, the evidence FOR belief – once recognized – is almost impossible to discount…

INTRODUCTION

  1. This website is a “living book” in defense of Religion — and MAGIC
  2. It is FREE, and STILL BEING WRITTEN — and re-written

  3. The suggestion here is that REALITY is, in fact, “magical” and “ultimately meaningful” — and, that the social-cultural systems that we call “Religions” are attempts to reveal the magic and promote the meaning
  4. I’m suggesting that religions are NOT just wishful thinking, and that the MAGIC to which they refer is REAL – that SOMEHOW, CAUSE AND EFFECT DOES NOT RULE


  5. Religion is a range of social-cultural systems, including designated behaviors and practices, morals, beliefs, worldviews, texts, sanctified places, prophecies, ethics, or organizations, that generally relate humanity to supernatural, transcendental, and spiritual elements—although there is no scholarly consensus over what precisely constitutes a religion.… Wikipedia

  6. It is easy to conclude that religious belief is simply WISHFUL THINKING
    1. In order to be truly happy, we humans need to believe in immortality and some sort of “ultimate meaning”
    1. We can’t be truly happy if we think we’re only mortal or ultimately meaningless
    1. And religions tell us that we ARE immortal and ultimately meaningFULL
    1. Whereas modern science doesn’t accept either claim

  7. The suggestion HERE however, is that religions don’t make sense to us well-educated homo-sapiens for several MISGUIDED reasons:
    1. Human intelligence is in its EVOLUTIONARY CHILDHOOD – WE’RE NOT AS SMART AS WE THINK WE ARE
      1. Our public schools are somewhat reasonably — but unfortunately and also unwittingly(?) — teaching our children that CAUSE-AND-EFFECT RULES, and indirectly, that religious beliefs ARE foolish! (If cause  and effect DOES rule, religious beliefs ARE foolish — no getting around it)
        1. The significant evidence AGAINST religion is OBVIOUS
        1. The significant evidence FOR religion is NOT OBVIOUS

  8. (Note that, on this site, I’ll be discussing WESTERN religions – EASTERN Religions may be easier to defend, but I don’t know enough about them to try)

  9. So, in other words, our Western schools are (for the most part, unknowingly) teaching our kids DETERMINISM… the doctrine that all events, including human action, are ultimately determined by causes external to the will.https://search.yahoo.com/yhs/search?spart=iba&hsimp=yhs-3&type=teff_10019_FFW_ZZ&grd=1&p=determinismhttps://search.yahoo.com/yhs/search?hspart=iba&hsimp=yhs-3&type=teff_10019_FFW_ZZ&grd=1&p=determinism
  10. And ATHEISM is the natural, logical, result

  11. Our schools and kids are more RATIONAL than ever
  12. And consequently, our kids have been leaving Religion in droves

  13. In other words, for the sake of reason and honesty, our public schools are undermining our kids’ happiness
  14. I’m all for reason and honesty — and respect the schools’ motivation — but MY BELIEF is that OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS just haven’t recognized the significant evidence FOR Religion, and are consequently doing our kids an enormous disservice…

  15. OUR CHURCHES AND SYNAGOGUES aren’t doing much better— they tell us a lot about WHAT to believe, but offer very little as to WHY to believe
  16. My aim here is to show that there are SERIOUS reasons to BELIEVE in MAGIC


  17. I’m NOT SURE that magic is real — but I BELIEVE that it is because I seem to have stumbled upon some magic STARING US ALL IN OUR FACES – we just haven’t recognized the implications
  18. That’s where I’m going — come along…

  19. Unfortunately, the significant evidence FOR religion isn’t NEARLY as OBVIOUS as is the significant evidence AGAINST religion – and consequently, religious parents and teachers of religion are not able to argue their cases very effectively
  20. And, if we parents want our kids to be happy, we need to learn about the significant evidence FOR, and pass it on to them — probably, all by OURSELVES

  21. The OBVIOUS PROBLEM we have with Religion is that what makes a “social-cultural system” a RELIGION is an underlying belief in “MAGIC”
  22. And most of us well-educated, western parents do not believe in magic.
  23. Or at least, most of us do not THINK that we believe in magic.
  24. But then, most of us actually do — we just haven’t made the necessary logical connections…

  25. For instance, reality is either a deterministic machine – or, it is (at least) somewhat “magical”
  26. There is no other possibility.
  27. And, if there is such a thing as FREE WILL, reality is NOT a deterministic machine.
  28. In other words, if you believe in free will, you already believe in magic.
  29. Keep that in mind as you judge western Religion

  30. If you DON’T believe in free will YET, just keep thinking

  31. More to come…

Moving right along…

  1. So, our first logical problem wth reality is that NOTHING SHOULD exist


  2. Maybe, our next logical problem is God…
  3. It is difficult enough to believe in “magic” in general, but to believe in something like AN ORIGINAL BEING WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR EVERYTHING ELSE IS ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE TO BELIEVE IN (if you’ve been well-educated in the U.S. or Europe)
  4. And, by the second grade, I was already worried that God was just another Santa Clause…

  5. From a well-educated-western point of view, it is quite difficult to believe in “God…”
  6. But again, I suspect that most of us well-educated westerners aren’t nearly as smart as we think we are
  7. And in trying to fully understand REALITY, we humans might be like chickens trying to understand Calculus

  8. But now there’s quantum mechanics, “universal consciousness” and the claim that consciousness naturally CARES (Look up “quantum theory of the soul” and “consciousness cares”)
  9. There would surely seem to be something magical, spiritual and religious about our own existences
  10. And, God is beginning to make sense
  11. And. here I am — which makes me absolutely CERTAIN that SOMETHING does exist
  12. And, if anyone else is reading this, you don’t know that I exist, but you do KNOW that SOMETHING does exist — YOU
  13. Even though, it would make much more sense if NOTHING existed
  14. The existence of nothing would make PERFECT sense
  15. Once SOMETHING exists, according to cause and effect, something must have always existed…
  16. But does THAT make sense?

  17. And, now’s your chance to fully appreciate the existence of your own personal consciousness, your own awareness, your own SELF
  18. Where (in the Hell) did you come from?
  19. And, how many POTENTIAL selves are there, anyway?
  20. Supposedly, homo sapiens have existed for 200,000 years and produced about 100,000,000,000 (ONE-HUNDRED BILLION) selves
  21. Is there a limit to the number of potential selves?
  22. Probably not…

  23. If you CAN exist for only one finite period of time at most, the PROBABILITY of you existing RIGHT NOW must be something like 8 billion over infinity. — which is nearly the same as ZERO
  24. This strongly suggests that you must exist MANY times — AT LEAST

  25. And, it isn’t just percentages that make this so cnvincing
  26. We each take our SELVES for granted – but they are the very last things that should be taken for granted
  27. This time, where in the Hell did WE ALL come from?
  28. I must be magical myself
  29. And, if anyone is reading this, you must be magical also

  30. So, where do our SELVES come from, anyway?
  31. As far as I can tell, science does not try to explain how that happens – how our PARTICULAR selves actually come to exist…
  32. Cloning (using the same DNA to reproduce bodies) apparently does not reproduce selves (accepting that lower animals have selves, and that 2 bodies sharing the same self would hinder if not prevent survival)

  33. What is the physical explanation for DIFFERENT selves?
  34. What is the physical explanation for YOU?
  35. Whatever — the consensus secular hypothesis about the mortality of our selves is that each of us can exist for only one finite time — at most

  36. What science does say is that consciousness is the “emergent property” of a large neuronal network
  37. And then — consciousness naturally involves a self
  38. And, if a self can have only one finite lifetime (at most), the odds of you ever existing must be virtually zero – and, the odds of you existing right now is much smaller

  39. Another way of explaining this probability (according to Stephen Hawking) is that before time there was an “initial singularity” of infinite mass that somehow led to the Big Bang, which happened to possess all the physical properties that would ultimately lead to you – right now…
  40. That must be a LOT of properties!
  41. How likely was that — that the Big Bang was exactly what was needed in order to eventually produce YOU, RIGHT NOW?
  42. The number of specific Big Bang characteristics needed to produce you right now may not be infinite, but neither are they countable
  43. And, what if time is infinite, and you can occur for only one finite time — at most?
  44. How ever a particular self comes about, the probability that it would exist for only one finite time, right now, must be less than one over a Googolplex)
  45. And, if you actually exist right now, you should expect that modern science is missing a dimension (or, something)
  46. In other words, the consensus “secular” hypotheses of human mortality right now – and the rule of cause and effect — ARE VERY LIKELY WRONG

  47. More to come
  48. https://what-it-s-all-about.life/chapter-4-2/